ANOREXIA NERVOSA IN CHILDREN
Anorexia nervosa has been reported beginning at age
four (4). Childhood anorexia should fulfill criteria
for adolescent- or adult-onset anorexia nervosa, except
that in children, due to a diminished amount of body
fat, a 25 percent weight loss is not necessary. In female
childhood cases, primary amenorrhea occurs.
The incidence of prepubertal anorexia nervosa is three
percent in a series of 600 consecutive patients of all
ages evaluated for anorexia nervosa at the Mayo Clinic
(5). Females comprise 73 percent of all reported children
with anorexia nervosa (4). However, in one subgroup
of anorectics (see below), 50 percent were males (6).
Developmental antecedents of childhood anorexia have
not been systematically research (7). Delaney and Silber
(8) evaluated approximately 30 cases and noted lack
of stage-specific negativism at age two, anxious clinging
behavior upon commencement of school, and difficulty
maintaining peer relations, leading to a degree of social
isolation.
In infants ages nine to 29 months, Chatoor and Egan
(9) described a developmental disturbance which they
consider to be both a separation disorder and a form
of infantile anorexia. These infants were noted to have
a diminished growth rate and food refusal. Feeding became
a battleground for maternal-infant autonomy struggles.
The infants resisted feeding as a manifestation of their
independence from an overwhelmingly strong maternal
figure. The child's fight for independence through anorexic
behavior is sharply contrated to the listless marasmic
pattern that characterizes the withdrawn underfeeding
in anaclitic depression (10).
Latency-age children, at the Piagetian stage of concrete
thinking, conceptualize food and water together as one
entity, resulting in global ingestive restriction. This
may lead to rapid weight loss and serious dehydration.
In addition, prepubertal children, especially girls,
have less body fat than their adolescent counterparts
and become more quickly emaciated (11). In Irwin's series,
over two-thirds of the children with anorexia were hospitalized
within six months of the onset of the anorexia. Gislason
(4) noted one death in 33 children with prepubertal
anorexia nervosa.
Sargent (6) described three subgroups of prepubertal
anorectics. The first group, similar to one described
by Pugliese et al. (12) severely restricted their food
intake, resulting in short stature. They had fears of
becoming obese, and by their deficient weight gain they
maintained both a physical and psychological immaturity.
The second group consisted primarily of prepubertal
females, ages ten to twelve, who were psychologically
pseudo-precocious, engaging in overt behavior more characteristic
of that of a pubescent 14-year-old. However, they were
described as being "lost little girls" underneath
this facade. Their parents discouraged age-appropriate
behavior and strongly encouraged their pseudo-adolescent
behavior. This female subgroup is closet to the pubertal-onset
anorexia nervosa. The third subgroup consisted of an
equal number of male and female anorectics who were
more psychologically impaired, having major ego deficits
with the occasional prescence of psychotic episodes
(13).
Gislason (4) noted premorbid personality characteristics
of dependency, timidity, schizoid traits, with features
of depression. Significant disturbances of ego development,
prepsychotic personality traits, and psychotic episodes
have been reported (4). However, these studies were
completed prior to the more precise DSM III diagnostic
criteria. Moreover, premorbid eating disturbances, including
a history of being a finicky eater, have been noted
(11).
Family patterns in childhood anorexia nervosa have
not been systematically studied. Family structural characteristics
found in adolescent anorexia nervosa, consisting of
rigidity, lack of conflict resolution, and triangulation,
appear to be present in the families of children with
the disorder (11). In childhood anorexia, Sargent (6)
noted increased divorce among families, as contrasted
to adolescent anorexia where the family divorce rate
is approximately equal to the general population.
The clinical manifestation of childhood anorexia nervosa
should fulfill most DSM III criteria. However, since
prepubertal children, especially girls, have less body
fat than their adolescent counterparts, a 15 percent
reduction in body weight should be sufficient for diagnosis
(11,14). These children, while recognizing that they
are thin, deny feeling fat. It is unclear if there is
a body image distortion equivalent to that of older
anorectics. Furthermore, no systematic comparative studies
in children have been undertaken. The child may be more
concerned with separation-individuation issues than
fears of sexuality (11,15). They frequently demonstrate
alexithymia, the inability to translate one's feelings
into words (16).
Overt or covert seduction or sexual abuse may be found
in the histories of some patients, although Bruch (17),
Blinder (18), and Piazza (19) question this hypothesis.
Sloan and Leichner (20) reported childhood sexual abuse
in a number of adult patients with bulimia nervosa.
Oppenheimer et al. (21) reported that two-thirds of
78 eating disorder patients spoke of distressing sexual
experiences as a child, including sexual abuse. However,
the significance of a history of sexual abuse for the
occurrence of anorexia nervosa remains unclear.
Many children with anorexia nervosa manifested signs
of depression. These feelings may be the result of helplessness
and ineffectiveness internally perceived and mirrored
from family attitudinal reactions. Studies reported
prior to DSM III did not utilize structured interviews
such as Kiddie SADS. In child anorectics, no formalized
studies specifying biochemical, diagnostic, or family
criteria for major depressive disorders have been reported.
While anorexia nervosa has been considered a variant
of affective disorder (22,23), the relationship between
childhood anorexia nervosa and affective disorder must
still be clarified.
Anorexia nervosa has been associated with Tourette's
Syndrome (stereotyped movement disorder) (24,25,26)
with Turner's Syndrome, a chromosome disorder with XO
genotype and gonadal dysgenesis (27), and with mental
retardation (28).
Piazza (19) reported anorexia nervosa in association
with childhood ulcerative colitis and ileitis. The patient
manifested typical bowel symptoms with diminished appetite,
and only upon careful questioning was the diagnosis
of anorexia nervosa determined. One child had anorexia
nervosa and abdominal complaints which initially masked
colitis.
The etiology of childhood anorexia is uncertain. Irwin
(11) feels dynamics in childhood anorexia nervosa are
similar to the dynamics of adolescent onset and include
identity disturbance, failure of separation/individuation
with fears of growing up, maladaptive attempts to be
in control, and failure of parents to resolve marital
or family conflicts. An alternative pattern may include
a child who is sensitive to family food preoccupation
and identifies with a family member who has an eating
disturbance.
Precipitating events associated with the onset of
childhood anorexia nervosa include: 1) the birth of
a sibling; 2) dereavement over the death of a parent
or relative; 3) a disappointment in object relations;
4) family discord; 5) viral illness; 6) peer criticism
about being fat; 7) the fear of becoming obses; 8) the
onset of breast development; 9) sexual abuse; 10) sustained
fear of choking while eating; 11) anticipated fear of
parental loss related to an ill or depressed parent;
and 12) the onset of a psychophysiologic disorder such
as ulcerative colitis (4).
In the treatment of the childhood anorectic, the therapist
should work closely with a pediatrician to rule out
medical and psychological conditions producing anorexia.
A physical examination and laboratory studies are mandatory
to monitor starvation effects which include: 1) hypotension;
2) syncope; 3) bradycardia; 4) hypothermia; 5) dry skin;
6) lanugo hair; 7) diminished triceps skin-fold thickness;
8) hypoglycemia; 9) hair loss; 10) sensitivity to noise;
11) leukopenia; 12) fatigue; 13) cardiac arrhythmia;
14) electrolyte disturbance; 15) hypothalamic dysfunction;
16) diminished thermoregulation; 17) hypercortisolism;
18) vasopressor regulation; 19) gastric ulcer; and 20)
initial motoric hyperactivity. Starvation can cause
psychological and cognitive disturbances including food
preoccupation, poor concentration, social isolation,
depression, and labile moods (29).
Children, especially those restricting both fluids
and food, may need immediate hospitalization. A children's
inpatient psychiatric unit can be effective in resolving
both physiologic and psychological problems (15,30).
The dietician must determine the appropriate caloric
intake for the child. Calories and nutrients not ingested
due to food refusal must be supplemented by liquid intensive
formula per mouth, or by tube feeding if necessary.
Parenteral hyperalimentation is rarely necessary for
childhood anorexia.
Most children's psychiatric inpatient unit use flexible
behavioral modification approaches to weight gain. Unlike
adolescent or adult behavioral programs, children should
be allowed to attend all ward activities regardless
of specific weight gain (15). Overactivity on the ward
must be monitored and controlled to avoid weight loss.
Panikar (31) used a wheelchair to restrain a severely
overactive child. The schizoid, withdrawn child can
be rewarded with points, tokens, etc., for engaging
in verbally expressive social interaction. More intensive
involvement of the family in the therapeutic pain may
have to await medical stabilization and emerging data
concerning developmental history, effects of separation
(positive and negative), and family strengths and liabilities.
Play therapy using projective techniques can be useful.
While children ages ten through twelve may feel too
old for play therapy, they may not be cognitively prepared
for verbal therapy. They may also be resistant in therapy;
therefore, therapeutic creativity is needed. Panikar
(16), noting alexithymia, draws smiling faces and asks
the childre to identify various moods. Affective expression
can be encouraged, such as in Gardner's "Thinking,
Talking, and Feeling Game" (32). Lucas (33) finds
art therapy to be particularly effective when compared
to play therapy which the anorectic child often resists
and obscures.
Feinstein (34) alternating both male and female therapists,
recognizes that the child can work through separate
conflicts with different therapists.
Sargent (6) modifies treatment according to the three
anorexic subgroups described above. In the first group
of anorectics, with growth retardation described by
Pugliese et al. (12) the social worker and nutritionist
meet on a regular basis to improve caloric intake. Pugliese
uses a cognitive approach, informing the children that
they need to eat to be strong and grow.
In Sargent's (6) second group of precocious females,
individual psychotherapy explores the child's underlying
separation, identity and sexual conflicts and her need
to recognize feelings of ineffectiveness and confusion.
The parents must recognize their need to push their
daughter into premature adolescence and must work with
a dietician to promote normal caloric intake.
In the third group, the therapist must assist the
child in recognizing his own sense of worth and must
establish a strong therapeutic alliance encouraging
normal ego development, interpreting, countering, and
ameliorating what may be a chaotic enviornment in the
family. The parents, often having severe psychopathology,
need to resolve their own conflicts to stabilize the
family. With such a family setting, a period of hospital
separation may be a beneficial opportunity for clarification,
intensive therapeutic focus on the child, and emergency
of diagnostically significant elements of family psychopathology
masked by the dramatic nature of the child's anorexia.
Chatoor (35), in her treatment of infantile anorexia,
uses ten food rules, including restricting a specific
meal time to thirty minutes and refraining from emotionally
laden comments. The goal is to allow the infant to reexperience
hunger in a neutral, time-limited setting. In some cases,
the mother may need to work through her own internal
conflicts (9).
The prognosis in childhood anorexia is unclear. Sargent
feels that the group II females have less individual
and family psychopathology, and have the most favorable
outcome as contrasted to group III, since both individual
and parental psychopathology are severe. The group I
prognosis is intermediate between groups II and III.
Delaney and Silber (8) noted male anorectics with a
poor prognosis and reported that many families have
been resistant to follow-up. Gislason (4) summarized
and reported cases of prepubertal anorexia and noted
that 63 percent improved, 21 percent did not improve,
and 3 percent died.
Russell (36) found prolonged delay of puberty (a late
menarche) and possible permanent interference with growth
in stature and breast development in children with prepubertal
anorexia nervosa. In contrast, Pfeiffer, et al (37),
noted relatively minimal growth retardation on a several-year
followup of treatment. He stresses the importance of
identifying childhood anorexia nervosa and returning
the children to an optimum weight to safeguard their
puberty. A long-term followup is necessary to accurately
determine prognosis.
Anorexia nervosa has been reported in prepubertal
children, many of whom appear to be more disturbed than
adolescents with the same disorder. The precise etiology
is uncertain, but life events centering on losses and
separation may be onset factors. Due to less body fat
and ingestive restriction of both food and water, this
disorder may be more ominous in children, necessitating
a rapid and vigorous therapy and frequently requiring
inpatient treatment. Prognosis is guarded and uncertain.
Furthermore, coexistent medical illnesses, colitis,
or ileitis require careful physical examination and
diagnostic procedures and comprehensive integrated treatment
and management.
|